This is an essay I wrote for the GRE Diagnostic test.
Now I know that my brain is rusty beyond recognition, and if you
disagree, just take a look at most of my old articles here..
Task 1: Issue Exploration (45 minutes)
"A person who does not thoroughly comprehend the technical side of a
craft is incapable of judging it."
Many craftsmen spent a lot of time honing their skills to make the
finest products possible, so it is not surprising that they took great
pride in their work. While most of us aren't as skillful, we are still
compelled to judge the quality of their work, and rightly so. This
might sound unfair, but let me explain.
There are 2 types of skill needed to be a successful craftsman. One is
making product, and the other is judging the quality of it. The first
one is difficult to obtain, however, the latter can be learned much
more easily -- sometimes we are born with it.
With that reason, someone who never cooks at all in his life can tell
if the food is delicious or not. Or, in the same vein, many of us can
judge about the quality of shoes, hammers, or a haircut. This mostly
happens in the crafts that make functional products for people to use.
Also, there are other kinds of related skills, such as between an
architect and a carpenter. An architect must design a building, but a
carpenter has to build it. So, does an architect know more about
carpentry than the carpenter? The answer is no, but they know enough
to design it.
However, there are also exceptions, which is mostly in the field of
art. One piece of art can generate a lot of different opinion, even
from artists themselves. As someone has said, "the picture is worth a
thousand words." -- Unfortunately, the words are not the same for each
person.
All in all, the person that can judge the craft correctly depends on
No comments:
Post a Comment